fbpx

From Flustered to Fearless: My Two-Year Journey into Sephora

Total U Founder, Kim, reflects on finding her way in Sephora. In the image, she stands in front of a brand sign.

There I was, a freshly minted 50-year-old, staring down the doors of beauty heaven—or what I thought was supposed to be heaven—aka Sephora. For context, I’d spent the last two decades with the same makeup routine. Foundation that matched my high school prom look? Check. Eyeshadow from the late ‘90s? Yep. Lipstick, re-bought in the same color year after year, even though that shade of mauve went out of style around the same time as MC Hammer parachute pants? Oh, absolutely.

But I thought that turning 50 was maybe, just maybe, the time to update my look. Something about my skin changing, makeup trends moving on, and the wonders of hyaluronic acid (is it a moisturizer? An acid? Both? Does it hurt?). So, off I went to Sephora with high hopes.

From the moment I walked in I was hit by a wave of neon lights, jumping music, and rows upon rows of products with names I couldn’t pronounce let alone know what they were used for. People half my age were confidently swatching colors that looked like they’d been pulled from a vibrant sunset—bright corals, shimmering golds, dreamy purples, all the while my skin-tone-matching prowess maxed out at “ivory” and “beige.”

I approached a display that looked like an easy starting point—moisturizers. Surely I could handle moisturizers, right? Wrong. Suddenly, I was confronted with choices like “plumping serum” and “age-defying elixir”. The labels talked about things like peptides and acids. I was overwhelmed. 

I couldn’t even muster up the courage to ask one of the store associates. I left. Sephora had won that day. I walked out, empty-handed, cheeks flushed—not from blush but from sheer embarrassment.

Why We Get Stuck on “Same Old, Same Old”

Let’s be real, how many of us are still rocking the same makeup look we started in our 30s? We’re creatures of habit. Once we find something that works, we’re all about loyalty, whether that’s in life, love, or lipstick. But our skin changes, our faces evolve, and staying stuck in the same routine can actually hold us back from looking our best.

It’s easy to get overwhelmed. The beauty industry thrives on launching a zillion new products daily. It’s normal to feel like we’re out of our depth, but just because things are new and complex doesn’t mean they’re out of reach. Embracing change is easier when we remind ourselves that we don’t have to become beauty experts—we just have to be open to trying something new.

Beauty Exploration Doesn’t Have to Be Scary

Here are some tips that I picked up along the way. 

  1. Start with ONE area. Pick something simple. If you’ve been sticking to the same foundation for years, why not try a formula with added skincare benefits? Look for brands that offer hydrating or illuminating options specifically designed for mature skin—yes, they really exist!
  2. Try sample sizes. Sephora, Ulta, and department stores offer samples or mini products. Grab a couple, test them at home, and see what works without commitment. You get the joy of trying new things without the fear of wasting money.
  3. Focus on skin care first. Instead of worrying about the perfect foundation, think about what’s underneath. Find a gentle, hydrating product that works for your skin now. Look for terms like “moisturizing,” “firming,” and “radiant,” which often target mature skin.
  4. Ask for recommendations (online or in real life). If you’re a bit shy, online reviews, YouTube tutorials, and blogs for mature beauty are lifesavers. It’s like a Sephora tutorial without the pressure of being in the store.
  5. Find a supportive community. Following women in their 40s, 50s, and beyond who are sharing their beauty journeys can be incredibly inspiring. Instagram, Facebook groups, and even in-person workshops can offer encouragement and real-life advice. And of course, you are welcome in our Total U Community!

Fast Forward Two Years…

So, did I finally return to Sephora? Yes! It only took a year of psyching myself up, watching a couple dozen YouTube tutorials, and leaning on my girlfriends for moral support. This time, I walked in with confidence and left with a bag of products actually tailored to my needs. I even asked questions. (Apparently, serums are my friend now.)

For any woman out there who’s staring down the beauty aisle with anxiety, remember this: it’s never too late to try something new. Our skin is constantly changing, and our beauty routines can too. Besides, it’s fun. Think of it as a little adventure—like climbing a mountain but with way less sweating.

Whether it takes you two minutes or two years to feel comfortable in a new beauty routine, just know you’re not alone. Try a little, test a little, and eventually, you’ll find what works for you. We’re all in this together!

Resources

Find Your Unique Self-Care Style

Our Total U Self-Care Quiz will help you discover what you need to nurture yourself, uniquely according to your lifestyle needs.